Clues Your Realtor Got Your Home Price Wrong

by Dr. David Reis

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
eXp Realty CT & eXp Realty NYC (NY)
Mobile: (203) 980-6811
e: david.reis@yourdoseofrealty.com

August 18, 2025

Pricing a home is part art, part science—and getting it wrong can cost you time, money, and peace of mind. The right realtor should know your market, study the data, and position your home smartly. But what if the price isn’t right? Here are some telltale clues your home may have been mispriced:

 

1. Your Home Has Lots of Showings… But No Offers

If buyers are walking through but no one is submitting an offer, it often means they like the home but not the price. Today’s buyers are well-informed—they’re comparing your property to others in the neighborhood. If they feel yours is overpriced, they’ll move on.

 

2. You’re Getting Lowball Offers Right Away

One or two low offers can happen in any market, but if every buyer is coming in far below asking, that’s a red flag. It could mean buyers believe your home isn’t worth the listed price, or your realtor overshot the market.

 

3. Your Listing Has Gone Stale

The first 30 days are critical. A home that sits too long without serious interest starts to look like “damaged goods.” Even if you later lower the price, buyers may assume something’s wrong with it.

 

4. Nearby Homes Are Selling, But Yours Isn’t

If other houses in your area with similar size and features are selling quickly, but yours lingers, the culprit is usually the price. Buyers will always choose the better value in the same neighborhood.

 

5. Your Home Was Priced on Emotion, Not Data

Sometimes sellers push for a price based on what they want to make, or realtors overpromise to win the listing. The best pricing comes from comparable sales (comps), current competition, and market trends—not wishful thinking.

 

6. You’re Constantly Adjusting the Price

If you’ve had to drop your asking price multiple times, that’s a clear sign the starting point wasn’t right. A well-priced home should attract strong interest right away without the need for repeated reductions.

 

What You Can Do Next

Ask for a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA): This gives you a snapshot of similar homes that sold recently.

Get Honest Feedback: Ask your realtor what buyers are saying after showings.

Consider a Fresh Strategy: Sometimes, a new marketing approach or even a new realtor can make all the difference.

 

Final Thought

Your home deserves to be positioned correctly from the start. Pricing it right means more buyer interest, stronger offers, and less stress for you. If you suspect your home was priced wrong, don’t wait—take action before the market passes you by.

Let’s Talk!

Let’s Talk! The entirety of living and working priorities and decision-making is shifting. It’s an amazing time to thinker colleagues to build by collaboration. Let’s connect and talk real estate business development.

Email

david.reis@yourdoseofrealty.com

Phone

(203) 980-6811

The views, opinions, and summary statements expressed in this presentation are those only of the presenter(s) (herein referenced as “opinion”) and do not represent official policy or policy positions of eXp World Holdings, it’s subsidiaries or vendor partners or clients (herein reference as “eXp”).

Any and all forward looking opportunity statements of participating in the practice of real estate within the operations of eXp Realty (residential), eXp Commercial, eXp international, or the use of or participation in the sale or representation of the capabilities of eXp in application are only the opinions of the presenter(s), and are subject to reinterpretation and change at any time.

Many factors will effect and determine your own particular results in using eXp’s resources, platform and capabilities, and no warrant or guarantee, stated or implied, is made in this media, that your own use case of eXp will result in outcomes similar to the presenter(s) or any outcomes referenced in corporate or public domain media by parties you may discover or who may outreach or market their media to you.

They contents of this media, and any media related to David G. Reis and/or any entities with which David G. Reis is associated carry disclaimers as above.

This media makes no representation of the operational and business models, expenses or financial success of real estate professionals at, joining or considering joining eXp.

Success as an associate at eXp is entirely a matter of your efforts.

Related Articles

Finding Purpose in Real Estate: A Career That Changes Lives

Finding Purpose in Real Estate: A Career That Changes Lives

Why "Just Selling Houses" Never Felt Like Enough Ask most new agents why they got into real estate, and you'll hear the same three answers: flexible schedule, unlimited income, be your own boss. Ask agents who've stayed in the business for ten, twenty, thirty years...

Can You Have Two Careers at Once? Yes! Here’s How I Do It

Can You Have Two Careers at Once? Yes! Here’s How I Do It

Let me guess. You clicked on this because somewhere in the back of your mind, there's a second career quietly tapping you on the shoulder. Maybe it's a passion you shelved years ago. Maybe it's a practical way to earn more. Or maybe — like me — you simply refuse to...

Why Real Estate Is One of the Best Careers for People with ADHD

Why Real Estate Is One of the Best Careers for People with ADHD

If you've ever been told your brain is "too much" for a 9-to-5 desk job, real estate might just be the career that finally makes sense of you. For a lot of people with ADHD, traditional office jobs feel like trying to fit a starfish into a square hole. Sitting still...

Let’s Talk!

 

Let’s Talk! The entirety of living and working priorities and decision-making is shifting. It’s an amazing time to thinker colleagues to build by collaboration. Let’s connect and talk real estate business development.

Email

david.reis@yourdoseofrealty.com

Phone

(203) 980-6811

The views, opinions, and summary statements expressed in this presentation are those only of the presenter(s) (herein referenced as “opinion”) and do not represent official policy or policy positions of eXp World Holdings, it’s subsidiaries or vendor partners or clients (herein reference as “eXp”).

Any and all forward looking opportunity statements of participating in the practice of real estate within the operations of eXp Realty (residential), eXp Commercial, eXp international, or the use of or participation in the sale or representation of the capabilities of eXp in application are only the opinions of the presenter(s), and are subject to reinterpretation and change at any time.

Many factors will effect and determine your own particular results in using eXp’s resources, platform and capabilities, and no warrant or guarantee, stated or implied, is made in this media, that your own use case of eXp will result in outcomes similar to the presenter(s) or any outcomes referenced in corporate or public domain media by parties you may discover or who may outreach or market their media to you.

They contents of this media, and any media related to David G. Reis and/or any entities with which David G. Reis is associated carry disclaimers as above.

This media makes no representation of the operational and business models, expenses or financial success of real estate professionals at, joining or considering joining eXp.

Success as an associate at eXp is entirely a matter of your efforts.